RentBuy

Market

Melbourne auction pullback deepens as reserve-price rules face their first spring test

Melbourne is heading towards an unusually quiet end to spring. Early evidence suggests transparent reserves are helping buyers, but rates, falling prices and the election make the rules’ wider effect difficult to isolate.

RentBuy Team

4 min read

Melbourne’s auction market is heading towards an unusually quiet finish to spring, with fewer sellers choosing to test the market and clearance rates remaining well below the levels usually associated with strong competition.

Cotality’s preliminary combined-capital clearance rate rose to 46.9 per cent in the week ending November 22, according to figures reported by The Australian Financial Review. That was an improvement of 2.9 percentage points, but still the second-lowest preliminary result of spring.

Separate realestate.com.au data put Melbourne’s weekend clearance rate at 57 per cent, based on 488 reported results from 636 scheduled auctions. Differences between providers reflect their collection methods and treatment of withdrawn or unreported properties, but both point to subdued conditions.

The more striking figure is the retreat in auction supply. Realestate.com.au reported that only 568 Melbourne auctions were scheduled for the final weekend of November, 68 per cent below the level a year earlier and the weakest end to November in its records, which begin in 2019.

Why auction numbers are shrinking

Auctions work best when several confident buyers compete for a property. Higher mortgage rates, declining values and uncertainty about employment have reduced the number of bidders willing or able to stretch beyond their initial limit.

Some vendors are responding by delaying their campaign or choosing a private sale. Others may be reluctant to advertise a reserve price in advance under Victoria’s new disclosure laws.

The state election on November 28 is another short-term complication. Sellers often avoid major political weekends, while buyers may pause until they know whether housing, tax or planning policies will change.

A falling auction count does not automatically mean every seller is distressed. It can instead show that owners who do not need to move are waiting, leaving a smaller pool of vendors who have clearer price expectations or a stronger reason to sell.

Reserve prices are now visible before auction day

Since October, Victorian agents have been required to publish the seller’s reserve as a single dollar amount at least seven days before an auction or fixed-date sale. Consumer Affairs Victoria says advertising must be updated to reflect that reserve, and the sale cannot proceed on the scheduled date if the price has not been published in time.

The reform is intended to reduce underquoting and help buyers avoid spending money on inspections, legal reviews and building reports for homes the vendor never intended to sell within the advertised range.

Early evidence suggests it is improving price information. Property platform Homer examined 2,164 Victorian auctions held between October 16 and November 14. ABC News reported that successfully auctioned properties sold for a median 0.9 per cent above their published reserve.

More than three-quarters of sold homes had reserves within their earlier advertised range. Properties with reserves above that range were also more likely to pass in than those priced consistently.

That indicates buyers are responding to unrealistic reserves before bidding starts rather than discovering the vendor’s expectation during the auction.

The law is not the only force at work

It is too early to conclude that reserve disclosure caused the fall in auction volumes. Guardian Australia noted that Sydney’s clearance rate had weakened even more than Melbourne’s after the Victorian rules began, suggesting national credit and market conditions remain the larger influence.

The rules also do not apply to an open-ended private sale without a fixed closing date. That creates an incentive for some vendors to avoid auctions, meaning the eventual test will be whether transparency improves across the market without simply moving campaigns into less regulated sales methods.

For now, the numbers describe a buyer-sensitive market. Sellers need evidence-based reserves and a plan for post-auction negotiations, while buyers should remember that a published reserve is useful information, not a guarantee that the property represents fair value.

What it means for you

  • Buyers can use the published reserve to decide whether due-diligence costs are justified before auction day.
  • Sellers should compare auction and private-sale strategies, but avoid setting a reserve based on last year’s market.
  • Treat weekend clearance rates as preliminary and compare figures from the same provider over time.