RentBuy

Market

Housing confidence sinks even as nearly 13% plan to buy

Westpac’s November survey found deeply pessimistic housing sentiment and sharply weaker price expectations, but a sizeable group of Australians still intends to purchase within a year.

RentBuy Team

4 min read

Australians have become more pessimistic about the housing market, yet nearly 13 per cent still say they plan to buy a home within the next 12 months.

That tension is the central finding from Westpac’s November Housing Sentiment Index, released on Tuesday. The index fell 2.2 per cent to 83.2, from 85.3 in October, placing housing-related confidence among its weakest readings since the measure’s components became available in 2005.

Westpac also introduced monthly questions about buying and selling intentions. It found 12.8 per cent of respondents planned to buy a home over the coming year, while only 8.2 per cent intended to sell one.

The results suggest that many prospective buyers have not abandoned home ownership. Instead, they may be waiting for greater certainty over prices, interest rates, employment or their household finances.

Price expectations changed sharply

Most of November’s deterioration came from a major downgrade in expectations for property prices.

The Westpac–Melbourne Institute House Price Expectations Index dropped 13.4 per cent to 99.6. A reading below 100 indicates that pessimists have moved slightly ahead of optimists, and it was the first sub-100 result since November 2022.

Respondents were almost evenly divided. Just over 38 per cent expected prices to fall, another 38 per cent expected an increase and 19 per cent anticipated little change. The remaining respondents were unsure.

That split is consistent with a market in which buyers can see improved affordability from lower prices but remain concerned about the cost and risk of borrowing.

The survey was conducted during the week in which the Reserve Bank lifted the cash rate to 4.85 per cent. Although the price of some properties has declined, higher interest charges can offset much of that benefit by reducing loan capacity and increasing monthly repayments.

Buyers see an opportunity, but not a safe market

Westpac’s time-to-buy-a-dwelling index improved by 1.3 per cent to 89.6. It remained firmly pessimistic, but the increase indicates that some households regard lower prices as an opening.

Buying intentions were particularly high in Queensland, where Australian Broker reported that roughly one in five surveyed consumers planned to purchase. Investor interest was also resilient nationally, with 11.2 per cent intending to buy an investment property.

Intentions are not the same as completed transactions. A respondent may hope to buy but be unable to secure finance, find a suitable property or accept the repayments required at current rates.

The survey nevertheless points to a potential pool of demand waiting outside the market. If economic conditions stabilise or buyers become confident that prices are near a floor, some of that demand could return quickly.

Sellers are cautious too

The relatively low 8.2 per cent planning to sell suggests hesitation is not confined to buyers.

Owners may be reluctant to list while values are falling, particularly if they do not face a pressing reason to move. Others may find that selling and purchasing another home would require replacing an older, cheaper mortgage with a larger loan at current rates.

For vendors already on the market, the survey offers mixed news. A substantial buyer pool still exists, but it is likely to be price-sensitive, financially constrained and willing to wait. Realistic pricing and clear evidence from recent comparable sales therefore become more important than relying on conditions from earlier in the year.

Buyers should avoid treating pessimistic sentiment as proof that prices have reached their lowest point. The survey measures how people feel and what they intend to do, not where values will move next.

A safer approach is to test a purchase against personal finances: repayments at a higher interest rate, secure income, ownership costs and the time the property is likely to be held.

What it means for you

  • A large group still wants to buy, but many appear to be waiting for better prices or greater economic certainty.
  • Lower property values do not automatically improve affordability when mortgage rates and repayments are rising.
  • Sellers may face cautious buyers now, while latent demand could return quickly if conditions stabilise.
  • Base a purchase on repayment capacity and a suitable holding period rather than trying to identify the exact market bottom.